4 Chapter 5: Ethics, Professionalism, and the Law in Healthcare

Introduction

Healthcare professionals must uphold both ethical and legal standards. This chapter explores the relationship between these standards, how they may align or conflict, and the systems in place to enforce accountability. The content also examines how institutional culture can affect ethical behavior and reporting.

Ethical and Legal Standards

Ethical and legal standards often overlap but are not identical. Some actions, like causing harm to a patient, are both unethical and illegal. Other times, ethical obligations go beyond legal requirements. In rare cases, ethical responsibilities may even conflict with laws, such as when protecting patient confidentiality versus complying with court orders.

[Insert Figure 1: Venn Diagram showing overlap and conflict between Ethical and Legal Standards]

The Role of the AMA

The American Medical Association (AMA) emphasizes that ethical obligations often exceed legal ones. Physicians should comply with laws but work to change unjust ones, and may need to prioritize ethics over law in rare cases. A physician found legally innocent may still have acted unethically.

 “Ethical obligations typically exceed legal duties.” – AMA Opinion

Professional Standards and the Law

Professional standards are influenced by laws like state medical practice acts. These laws establish licensing boards, oversee testing and discipline, and define what constitutes professional behavior. Courts may also interpret whether a healthcare professional met acceptable standards, even in the absence of specific legal violations.

[Insert Figure 2: Flowchart showing connection between state law, medical boards, and enforcement actions]

State Medical Boards

Boards include both medical professionals and public members. They license physicians, investigate misconduct, and impose sanctions such as:

• Fines
• Mandatory continuing education
• Required treatment for medical issues (e.g., substance use)
• Suspension or revocation of licenses
• Other healthcare professions such as nursing and pharmacy have equivalent state boards.

[Insert Table 1: Typical Responsibilities of a State Medical Board]

Medical Malpractice

Malpractice occurs when a healthcare provider breaches their duty of care, causing injury and damages. A physician can be held accountable both legally (malpractice lawsuit) and professionally (board discipline).

The four elements of a malpractice claim are:

A duty existed between the provider and the patient.

The provider failed to meet the standard of care.

This failure caused an injury.

The injury resulted in damages or harm.

[Insert Figure 3: Illustration or diagram of the “Four Elements of Medical Malpractice”]

Malpractice can apply to all types of healthcare professionals—not just doctors.

Culture and Ethical Challenges

The culture of healthcare values independence and self-regulation, but this can make it difficult to report unethical behavior. Fear of disciplinary action or disloyalty to peers can cause professionals to remain silent, even in the face of clear misconduct.

[Insert Figure 4: Graphic showing tension between “idealism” and “fear of consequences” in reporting misconduct]

The Hidden Curriculum

Medical students learn not only through formal education but also from institutional culture—called the “hidden curriculum.”
They absorb values by:

Observing who is promoted or recognized

Hearing how financial success is discussed

Noting which programs receive funding

Picking up language that reflects business priorities over ethical concerns

[Insert Figure 5: Concept Map of Hidden Curriculum Factors – policies, evaluation, resource allocation, language]

Barriers to Whistleblowing

Barriers that prevent professionals from reporting misconduct include:

Personal motivations: Fear of retaliation or conflict

Institutional motivations: Avoiding scandals or negative publicity

Cultural norms: Expectations to stay silent, appear confident, and not question authority

Studies show that fewer than 5% of medical students nearing graduation say they would report unethical behavior.

[Insert Table 2: Common Barriers to Whistleblowing in Healthcare]

Whistleblower Protections

Some federal laws protect whistleblowers from retaliation:

False Claims Act: Covers reporting of fraud (e.g., Medicare/Medicaid fraud)

Occupational Safety and Health Act (OSHA): Covers unsafe work conditions

Environmental Acts: Cover violations in waste disposal or air quality

Despite these protections, about 15% of whistleblowers face retaliation, including being:

Snubbed by coworkers

Verbally abused

Denied promotions or raises

In extreme cases, experiencing property damage or physical harm

[Insert Figure 6: Chart showing whistleblower cases and types of retaliation – adapted from 2011 data]

[Insert Table 3: Examples of Whistleblower Protections and Applicable Laws]

---

Adapted from Oregon Health & Science University, funded by the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services